Difference Between American Eagle vs. American Buffalo Gold Coins 

1 Oz American Eagle Gold Coin
1 Oz American Eagle Gold Coin

American Eagle vs. American Buffalo Gold Coins: A Collector’s Guide

Gold coins hold a special allure, and in the United States, two names stand out: the American Eagle and the American Buffalo. Both are prized for their beauty, purity, and status as legal tender, yet they differ in ways that appeal to different collectors and investors. Let’s delve into the distinctive features of each to understand their unique place in the world of gold coins.

Origin and Issuance: A Tale of Two Coins

Both the American Eagle and American Buffalo gold coins are issued by the United States Mint, a key player in the country’s coinage since 1792. The American Eagle was first minted in 1986, part of a series that includes silver and platinum coins. The American Buffalo, introduced in 2006, was America’s answer to 24-karat gold coins like the Canadian Maple Leaf, offering a purer gold option compared to the 22-karat Eagle.

Design and Artistry: Aesthetics that Tell a Story

The American Eagle gold coin boasts a design steeped in American history. The obverse features Augustus Saint-Gaudens’ iconic Lady Liberty, a symbol of freedom and hope, striding forward with a torch in one hand and an olive branch in the other. The reverse, designed by Miley Busiek, depicts a male eagle returning to his nest, where a female eagle and their hatchlings await. This imagery resonates with themes of family, unity, and national pride.

1 Oz American Buffalo Gold Coin
1 Oz American Buffalo Gold Coin

In contrast, the American Buffalo gold coin showcases the classic design of James Earle Fraser’s 1913 Buffalo Nickel. The obverse features the profile of a Native American, a composite of several tribe leaders’ features. This design pays homage to America’s indigenous people and their rich heritage. The reverse proudly displays an American Bison, a symbol of the West’s wild and untamed spirit.

Metal Content and Purity: A Matter of Karat

One of the most significant differences between these two coins lies in their composition. The American Eagle is 22-karat gold, alloyed with silver and copper to enhance durability. This makes the Eagle more resistant to scratches and dents, an advantage for handling and circulation. The American Buffalo, on the other hand, is 24-karat gold, which means it’s made of 99.99% pure gold, offering a higher level of purity for collectors seeking the finest gold content.

The Significance of Gold Bezel Settings

For those looking to wear these gold coins as jewelry, a gold bezel is an elegant solution. It encircles the coin, allowing it to be worn as a pendant without damaging the coin’s edges. The bezel setting not only adds a decorative touch but also protects the coin, making it a practical choice for showcasing these pieces of American heritage.

Investment Value: Weighing Your Options

Both coins are popular among investors and collectors. The American Eagle, with its historic design and slightly more robust composition, is often chosen by those who value tradition and durability. The American Buffalo, with its higher gold purity, appeals to purists and those who prioritize the intrinsic value of gold.

Legal Tender and Face Value

It’s important to note that while both coins have a face value (the Eagle at $50 and the Buffalo also at $50 for the 1 oz version), their market value is determined by the current gold spot price, making them worth much more than their face value.

The Gold Content of American Eagle vs. Buffalo Coins

The American Eagle gold coin has consistently been minted with 22-karat gold since its introduction in 1986. This composition, also known as “crown gold,” contains 91.67% gold, alloyed with silver and copper. The choice of 22-karat gold for the American Eagle was deliberate, aimed at enhancing the coin’s durability while maintaining a high gold content. This composition ensures that the coin is less susceptible to wear and tear, making it ideal for circulation and physical handling.

In contrast, the American Buffalo gold coin, introduced in 2006, is made of 24-karat gold, equivalent to 99.99% purity. This was a strategic move by the United States Mint to offer a pure gold coin option in response to the increasing global demand for 24-karat gold coins. The American Buffalo thus stands alongside other pure gold bullion coins, like the Canadian Maple Leaf, appealing to investors and collectors who prefer the highest possible purity in gold bullion.

American Eagle Gold Coin, Lady Liberty
American Eagle Gold Coin, Lady Liberty

Choosing What Resonates with You

In the end, whether you opt for the American Eagle or the American Buffalo gold coin depends on what you value most – the historical and symbolic significance of the Eagle or the pure gold content of the Buffalo. Each coin tells a unique story of America’s rich history and offers a different appeal to gold enthusiasts. Both stand as testaments to the nation’s legacy in precious metal minting, making either choice a worthy addition to any collection.

Category: Gold Coins, Gold Jewelry, Gold, Stocks, Crypto, Jewelry Guide, Jewelry History

Leave a Reply