If you are looking for a more religious tone for your jewelry, this At the Foot of the Cross toe ring in 14K gold from Apples of Gold Jewelry is a wonderful toe ring to add to your collection.
The band of this ring is textured and splits into two around the middle of the ring, forming a cut out design. On the bottom of the toe ring the cross measures 4mm wide. On the top of the ring, where the band widens a bit, there is a brightly polished cross. The band and the cross on the top of the ring measure 8mm in width.
"And all things, whatsoever ye shall ask in prayer, believing, ye shall receive." (Matthew 21:22)